Platon’un Apologia’sındaki Sokrates’in Kişiliğine Yeni Bir Bakış

Haydar DÖNMEZ   278–290 | Download


Abstract: Socrates is one of the most interesting and enigmatic philosophers in the history of philosophy. In 399 BC he was tried by the Athenian court and executed. The accusers brought three accusations against him: impiety, introducing new gods and corrupting young men. Socrates wrote nothing. Therefore, information about his personality and thoughts is based on writings of his students and contemporaries. Works by Plato, Xenophon and Aristophanes give considerable information, but Socratic images of these writers are inconsistent with each other. This paper tries to take a new look at the personality of Socrates in the Apology of Plato. The Socratic image created by modern scholars is generally positive: honest, wise, democrat, devout, truth-lover. My paper focuses on the obvious contradictions of Socrates in the Apology and tries to disprove his views confirmed by modern scholars. It comes to conclusion that Socrates fails to make a good defence before the jury.

Keywords: Socrates; trial; apology; Athenian court; Greek philosophy.



Arslan 2010

A. Arslan, İlkçağ Felsefesi Tarihi 2, İstanbul 2010.

Cartledge 2013

P. Cartledge, Pratikte Antik Yunan Siyasî Düşüncesi, (çev. K. Tanrıyar), İstanbul 2013.

Copleston 1997

F. Copleston, Ön-Sokratikler ve Sokrates, (çev. A. Yardımlı), İstanbul 1997.

Dorion 2005

L. A. Dorion, Sokrates, (çev. M. N. Demirtaş), Ankara 2005.

Guthrie 1972

W. K. C. Guthrie, Socrates, Cambridge 1972.

Hadot 2011

P. Hadot, İlkçağ Felsefesi Nedir?, (çev. M. Cedden), Ankara 2011.

Mantouri 1990

M. Mantouri, The Oracle Given to Chaerephon on the Wisdom of Socrates. An Invention by Plato, Kernos 3, l990, 251–259.

Nehamas 2002

A. Nehamas, Yaşama Sanatı Felsefesi: Platon’dan Foucault’ya Sokratik Dü­şü­nümler, (çev. C. Soydemir), İstanbul 2002.

Ober 2011

J. Ober, Socrates and Democratic Athens, şurada: D. R. Morrison (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Socrates, Cambridge 2011, 138–178.

Papadimitriou 2012

A. Papadimitriou, Pro Atheniensibus Contra Socratem, 2012 (http://www.

Popper 1989

K. R. Popper, Açık Toplum ve Düşmanları, Cilt I: Platon, (çev. M. Tunç­ay), İstanbul 1989.

Popper 2001

K. R. Popper, Daha İyi Bir Dünya Arayışı, (çev. İ. Aka), İstanbul 2001.

Samons 2013

L. J. Samons II, Demokrasinin Nesi Var?, (çev. Y. Erdemli ), İstanbul 2013.

Selçuk 1995

S. Selçuk, Sokrates ve ‘Savunma’sı, Türkiye Günlüğü Dergisi 37, 1995, 29–30.

Stone 1988

I. F. Stone, The Trial of Socrates, New York 1988.

Taylor 2002

C. C. W. Taylor, Düşüncenin Ustaları / Sokrates, (çev. C. Atila), İstanbul 2002.